The Smell of Bullshit, part 78: That Pesky Public

In part 77, we talked about Lush’s campaign related to the undercover police officers nicknamed “spy cops,” and how upset many of the public were. A little while ago, I received this email from a Lush staff member.

Advertisements

The Smell of Bullshit, part 77: Another Lush Campaign Upsets People

Several years ago the press revealed that the Metropolitan Police had sent officers undercover into various organisations, to infiltrate the organisations and get evidence of criminal activity. During their undercover time, several of the officers began relationships with women, who were understandably distraught when the truth of their identities were revealed.

I don’t know enough about police work to comment on whether infiltrating groups is common or acceptable police behaviour. I don’t know whether any of those police officers genuinely fell for the women they had relationships with, or whether it was all manipulation and abuse of power. Only the officers involved know that and regardless of any real feelings they might have had, those relationships were strictly forbidden. Certainly the women involved feel that they were manipulated, abused and deceived.

When this information first became public, Mark Constantine had a right bee in his bonnet about it. He posted about it on the Lush forum a lot, along with posts about news reports of MI5 and MI6 using torture or information gained by torturing suspects. He didn’t often post on the forum about anything but he had a lot to say about these issues, in his usual pretentious, trying to be cryptic, pseudo-intellectual way.

Now, Lush believe that the public inquiry into the claims of wrongdoing by the undercover officers is protecting officers, and they have chosen to draw attention to this by what might be their most over the top and not in a good way campaign yet.

Lushspycops

On their website, Lush say

“This is not an anti-state/anti-police campaign. We are aware that the police forces of the UK are doing an increasingly difficult and dangerous job whilst having their funding slashed. We fully support them in having proper police numbers, correctly funded to fight crime, violence and to be there to serve the public at our times of need.

This campaign is not about the real police work done by those front line officers who support the public every day – it is about a controversial branch of political undercover policing that ran for many years before being exposed. Our campaign is to highlight this small and secretive subset of undercover policing that undermines and threatens the very idea of democracy.”

But unsurprisingly, the public are seeing it as an attack on all police. Thousands of people on social media are threatening to boycott Lush, their facebook reviews had approx 16,000 one star reviews added overnight, and at least one shop has removed the campaign from its window (note to staff: make sure you’ve joined a union for when the shit comes down on you).

LushGateshead

The thing that bugs me most about this is – Lush knew that this window display would trigger strong reactions from the public, and they clearly didn’t give a fuck about how that would affect the frontline shop staff. I’m sure that 99.99% of police officers are professional enough not to let this ill-conceived campaign affect their attitude to their work, but if I worked in a shop with that display up, I’d be at best embarrassed and at worst reluctant to call the police to an emergency situation. Some Lush staff used to be police. Some police used to be Lush staff. Lots of Lush staff have family who are police. Lush can’t have given a second’s thought to what this display would feel like to those staff. And what of the women abused by these few police officers? How do they feel, going into town for a bit of shopping and finding their trauma all over a shop window, selling increasingly laughable products at increasingly inflated prices?

Of course the prices are inflated; Mark keeps giving his money away.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/countryside/8320508/Millionaire-backer-of-hunt-sabs-and-eco-militants-in-talks-to-fund-police-crime-unit.html

http://www.bournemouthecho.co.uk/news/14370428.Lush_founder_donates___30k_to_Martyn_Underhill_s_PCC_campaign/

Edited to add: how do the abused women feel about the campaign?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-44356733

The Smell of Bullshit, part 75: Whistleblowing in the Wind

An email from a Lush employee (edited to remove some identifying details).

The Smell of Bullshit, part 74: Consistency (Constantincy?), Thy Name is Not Lush

A couple of emails have come into the blog over the past few days (emails to southside socialist at hotmail dot co dot uk) which suggest that the problems within Lush previously raised by employees here haven’t been resolved. This is one of them, with identifying details omitted.

The Smell of Bullshit, part 73: Fire Hazards and Sexual Harassment – What a Place to Work!

Another email from an ex-employee of Lush, who worked at a shop in south-east England. I’m not going to reproduce it here whole because I don’t want the woman identified, and also, some of what she says could well entice the trolls who think women are asking for it. There is some discussion of sexual harassment in this post.

The Smell of Bullshit, part 72: So.Much.Fail.

 

A couple of emails from  two ex-employees of everybody’s favourite ethical employer, Lush. The people have asked me to only use excerpts rather than the whole emails, so I’m picking out the worst bits, some of which are a) despicable, b) unlawful and c) cruel. Some of these issues could have been dealt with by a union, or a decent HR department, or a competent, well-trained manager who understands employment law and has a soul.

 

 

The Smell of Bullshit, part 71: Mica Morals Missing

Two years ago, this blog reported on a Guardian investigation into the use of child labour to produce mica for cosmetics companies. The Grauniad reported that Lush had committed themselves to removing all mica from their products as they were unable to guarantee it was produced without child labour.

Two years on, how are they getting on with that pledge?

Surprise surprise! The Guardian says “the company has been unable to eradicate the mineral from its supply chain.” Lush say they haven’t knowingly bought any materials containing natural mica since 2014, but they also say “as a direct ingredient it would be easy to identify, but unfortunately mica remains as part of a complex mix of materials that are used to make colour pigments and lustres.” The article also says that Lush say they don’t have the local knowledge or purchasing power to stay and make a difference, but given that several other companies are working in the area to get children to school instead of mines, you’d think they could join in. Several companies, according to the article, have committed to only buying mica from legal and fenced mines, where child labour is less likely to be involved, as well as ending relationships with mines where audits showed child labour was used. But they all acknowledge it’s impossible to be 100% sure child labour was not involved. But, here’s the thing.

Which is more moral? Continuing to produce products even though you’re not 100% sure they didn’t involve child labour? Or discontinuing the products until you can be sure you have a child labour-free option?

 

poll=0]

They’re happy to crow about their ethics though.

BIG thank you to the reader who let me know about the articles.

The Smell of Bullshit, part 70: across the pond

An email has come in from a reader in the USA (emails to southside socialist at hotmail dot co dot uk, please) which the writer has given me permission to share.

 

My ex-coworkers and I have been following this blog for a while now (we no longer work for lush but Stay in touch), and I figured it was about time I shared what I learned in my 2.5 years with LushCosmetics here in the USA.

I have a whole lot to say, but I will begin by saying this –

The pay issue is just as bad here in the states, if not worse. Employees here cannot pay their bills unless they have more than one job. They are expected to do and know more than anyone in the business, and put up with the low pay, verbal abuse, shady management with zero accountability, and in come cases, straight-up sexual harassment and religious discrimination.

Because of that sweet, sweet lush Kool-aid of, “we care about the planet. No other company cares like we do, and you’re LUCKY to be employed with us. You’re LUCKY to be paid $.xx more than minimum wage. You should THANK us.”

So my tale begins-

I began working for lush years ago, and had a friend who had been with them for a while and enthused non-stop about how great her job was. They were opening a shop nearby and doing interviews in a couple weeks so I researched and prepared myself, and ultimately got the job. Of course they trained us and had us worshipping the almighty MC by the end of our first day of training. Even I thought it was weird though, how the people training us would say things like “Oh my god here’s a picture of me SHAKING HIS HAND. I can’t BELIEVE he touched me!” Which is something that I feel is reserved for people who are, at least, talented.

Six months in, our new shop was already experiencing serious problems due to our manager. We did not have an MIT for quite a while, and our 23-year-old manager from Oklahoma was more interested in the big city lifestyle than running our shop. She often would not come in to work to manage because she was hung over, and the majority of the work was left to four people, myself and three others. Two were employees of Lush for 1+ years and had some idea of how to manage things, and the other two of us learned very quickly that this situation was commonplace, and that lush has no accountability to those in charge. One of the girls who was an employee who transferred and had been the Product Knowledge guru of her old shop (we are still friends today) basically trained me and a few of the other girls herself, while the other two girls tried their best to make sure product came in on time and generally manage as best they could. We got by somehow, but needless to say, it was an almighty mess. Our manager also took to hiring a young man PURELY DUE TO HER SEXUAL ATTRACTION TO HIM. I don’t think any of us realized it until maybe a month in, when she began making passes at him. She made sure they were scheduled together so she could talk ceaselessly about things she would be willing to do for a man in bed, which disgusted us all. She often confided that she only hired him because she wanted to have sex with him, and hoped he would take the hint and ask her out, much to our horror.

She was later fired, but not until he had filed many complaints to HR with no response until he threatened to file a lawsuit. He told me he got a settlement when I discussed it with him later, but he did not disclose the amount. Whatever it was, it wasn’t enough I’m sure.

I ended up moving cities for family reasons, and transferred locations to stay in the company. My new shop was much more high-volume and I had trouble adjusting, but eventually settled in and made new friends in the shop. At some point shortly after my arrival at the new shop, our manager quit to pursue her own business (I never had any real issues with her, beyond her insistence that she was an original punk-rocker despite being in her late 30’s at the oldest and generally being very condescending, but many of the older employees had complaints about her unsurprising tendency towards favoritism). There was a new MIT, who had started in the shop the same time I did and had transferred from a large makeup chain store.

And this is where it gets interesting.

She was left for 6 MONTHS to manage the shop by herself, and it became very clear that she is the kind of person that, as a wise man once said, should never ever be given the clipboard of authority. Every time I opened the shop with her, she would show up 20 minutes late, and she would never adjust my pay for it. She told me on multiple occasions that she clocked in on her cell phone while she was on her way to work so her time would appear correct. As time went on, and she realized that no one could stop her from doing anything she wanted, she began to verbally harass some of the members of our staff that were particularly sensitive – namely, one who suffered from extreme anxiety, and essentially cornering her, threatening to fire her for her “attitude,” and sending her home crying – and money and product began to go “missing” every morning she worked and was counting the cash and getting the product (seeing as she believed she was the only one capable of doing these things, despite her inability to even show up on time), and then saying that she now needed to search our bags upon arrival and departure from our scheduled work hours, which is not only against Lush policy but AGAINST MANY PRIVACY LAWS IN THE USA WITHOUT A WARRANT. She also began to harass some of the employees who were in college, who dutifully turned in their availability sheets before the final deadlines with time to spare, and were nonetheless told they were expected to come into work, and that failure to do so would result in being fired.

At some point, we all got fed up. And one particular girl, whom we will call Tracy, was more or less the ringleader. “Something needs to change. We need to contact HR. What do we do?” I mentioned the stress that my ex-coworker had gone under when experiencing sexual harassment and told them that I didn’t believe anything beyond a lawsuit would get their attention, but we were reminded by Tracy that lush requires upon hiring that we sign a nice, neat little agreement that any issues we have with the company will be settled outside of the US court system. So we all banded together, and decided that we would all email HR ourselves. And remember, this was 20+ women at once, all emailing their stories to HR. All of them agreeing with each other and everything checking out. We believed that Lush would care, and that’s where we went wrong, because Tracy was the only one to receive a response. And what did Lush’s HR department have to say for 20+ employees recognizing abuse, theft, and harassment from the person THEY left in charge?

They quite literally emailed Tracy with a single sentence – “What do you want US to do about it?”

It was at this moment that I believe the collective disillusionment began in our shop. None of us knew what to do. Many of us resolved to quit, but of course didn’t because we were part of an elaborate cult now and didn’t know how to get out. As you’ve stated before in the blog, it’s insidious and genius how they hand-pick people who care enough to accept less than they’re worth for a “cause.” It’s well-documented so I won’t get into it.

They sent someone to help as the holiday seasons started, and a new manager was given to us. I liked her at first (truly no one could possibly be worse than that MIT so rose-colored glasses were donned for a while). However, she was a very, VERY religious person and incredibly pushy about politics too. Her more-or-less nice personality became less and less important than telling employees regularly that anyone who takes Birth control pills is a waste of taxpayer dollars, and that abortion for any reason was wrong, and that gay marriage should never be legal or okay, under ANY circumstances. (All of us wondered retrospectively why she wanted to work for lush in the first place.) She often went on tirades about this, then of course shifting gears at realizing how illegal her 5-minute slut shaming speech saying “But that’s just my opinion!” She often made interesting anti-Semitic remarks in my presence (many people of her religion are known to teach in their circles that the Holocaust was fabricated propaganda. Disgusting), at one point, when going on about how health insurance should only be available to people who are members of a religious congregation (LOL) and myself and two other employees politely disagreeing with her, she then targeted me and said

“Well why don’t you get your little Jew friends together and figure it out then? You have plenty of money and doctors anyway.”

This is more or less when I decided to quit, so I began seeking new employment.

In the month between finding new employment and this decision, she fired one of the employees there who had helped open the shop 5 years previously who was also a tremendous help to many of the newer employees AND THE MANAGER AND MIT, and she was told she was being fired for her “insubordination.” The manager then made a point to call EVERY SINGLE ONE of the employees to inform them that she had fired her. It was probably the single most malicious thing I have ever seen a manager do. My ex-coworker was fired, then irreversibly embarrassed in front of all her coworkers. Tracy and another coworker whom we shall call Lorraine did not seem at all surprised. It then came to light later that Lorraine had gotten close to the manager and convinced her to fire our coworker so she could move into her position. Tracy was then promoted to MIT, and seemed perfectly fine with the way HR was handling things now, since she got something out of it.

After this I had my new job, and it was no longer really my problem. But it’s worth noting that I was given a hell of a lot of grief for leaving, especially because I put in my two weeks, and the manager decided to continue scheduling me anyway because a local event left the shop short-handed. I flatly refused to work, as the new job was offering me $300/day while she was offering me 5 hours of work for $10/hour. I apologized of course, as I knew I would miss my coworkers and expressed my desire to help out during the holiday season, but when I applied for seasonal, none of the 4 Lush’s in my city called me back after they spoke with her, despite expressing lots of enthusiasm after talking with them myself.

We have heard story after story since we left – everything from the issues of Tracy accusing someone of sexual harassment in the shop when she was trashed and was the one doing the sexual harassing, to Lush claiming to have no money to train new employees for the holidays while sending managers and manufacturing staff on 5-star weeklong vacations to party all over the world, to managers in my old city disappearing with MC during manager “training” events and showing up with him the next morning bragging about his “choosing” them for the honor of riding his dick. (Sorry to be crass, but it’s true. And disgusting.)

This company is a joke. I still meet up with my old coworkers from time to time to discuss things, and all we get is more angry and sad. Even with this huge email, there is so much that’s happened that I can’t even begin to say. But it all amounts to the same thing.

I always hope that the girls and guys working for this awful company will stand up and step away – that’s the point of capitalism, right? You don’t like your job, you don’t like your pay, you go somewhere else, right? Because of Lush’s insidious culty system, many of these people end up feeling emotionally trapped. They’re scared to speak up because, as it is well-documented, management has no problem making you feel worthless for needing other employment, or to further your education, and throw you out on the street for the next unemployed vegan to come along and take your place, and often for much less money.

And even almost a year later, I can’t even think of a solution, because there are so many people who shop at lush and think it’s just such a great, ethical company. Everyone’s smiling, aren’t they?

It’s like Neil Gaiman’s Coraline.

“Everything will be perfect, you can save the planet, if you just let me sew on your button-eyes.”

And they don’t give a damn about the health, well-being, or psychological disposition of their employees.

Anyway, thanks again so much for making this blog. It’s so important that the word gets out. I can’t tell you how much solace it’s given those of us who have put up with it for years and thought we were the only ones.

 

So, my message to all Lush employees, no matter what country they are in, is the same – find out about your legal rights to join a union, and then join. If you’re worried that your employer isn’t that bothered about your employment rights, a union can help.

The Smell of Bullshit, part 69: still more alternatives

In posts 44, 54, 56 and 62 I looked at alternatives to Lush, especially alternatives to Dream Cream, which is the only thing for which I have struggled to find an alternative.

Burt’s Bees seems to be where it’s at. Unfortunately it’s not vegan, but for non-vegans, it’s definitely worth a try. The Beeswax & Banana handcream is pretty good, as is the Almond & Milk. Would buy both again, as they’re moisturising and for me, non-irritating, and smell great. I will try the hand salve at some point too. But my favourite is the Shea Butter Hand Repair Cream. It smells wonderful (I love rosehip), it soothes, moisturises, and clears up eczema scabby bits overnight, and it stops skin itching. It works really well on my oddly scabby right elbow too.

Best thing I’ve found so far.

Cat in a Flat Edinburgh Southside

Caring for the City's Cats

Hollie Poetry

Spoken Word. Poetry. Workshops

Dr. Jen Gunter

Wielding the lasso of truth

Belfast Child

Remembering the Victims

thepetauthority

The Pet Authority's Official Blog

The Lab Report

Fake pet news. Follow us on Twitter @hellolabreport

Captain Awkward

Advice. Staircase Wit. Faux Pas. Movies.

Gazzetta della Rum Fucker

Italian Mancunian woman with an unholy love of cake. Blogs for the politically angry, but personally pleasant.

Caro's Creams

Handmade herbal creams and salves

LoneSwimmer

The World's Best Guide To Cold & Open Water Swimming

Sarah Ditum

Writing, etc.

Lisa O'Donnell

Writer of The Death of Bees and Closed Doors out July 4th 2013.

Tales of One City

Edinburgh Libraries blog

Irregularly Irregular

Just another WordPress.com site

The Secret Diary of a Beauty Counter Girl

Exposing the myths, monsters and misogyny.

Iain Macwhirter

Read Iain in The Herald and Sunday Herald, every Wednesday and Sunday.

The Chronicles of Pete

A Somnolent Rescue Cat

Feminist Philosophers

News feminist philosophers can use

Making Sense of Modern Fitness

Trekking through a super-saturated, over-bloated industry

leaving the shadow

of a billion pound killing machine

Feminists Unknown's Blog

Together We Are Stronger

Happy is the new healthy

…finding my healthy and smiling the whole way!

OT on wheels

Just another WordPress.com site

Paul Bernal's Blog

Privacy, Human Rights, Law, The Internet, Politics and more

the void

narking off the state since 2005

Springs1's Blog

Just another WordPress.com weblog

...a can opener in a worm factory...

The skull beneath the skin: sex, food, subjectivities.

quiteirregular

Jem Bloomfield on culture, gender and Christianity

Helen Blackman

Riding; cycling; writing

Edinburgh Bakers

Formerly known as the Edinburgh Cake Ladies

sisterhoodispowerful

Radical Feminist Resistance

Davena's Deliberations

My personal take on politics, life and the world

Media Diversified

Analysis. Stories. Aesthetics. By and from the diaspora.

philrotica

sexy tales of the former genesis drummer